SEARCH PROCEDUREIN THE DUTCH LIBRARY SYSTEM
(originally uploaded 1997 by the University of Maastricht, uploaded here in September 2002)Friedrich Lists Einfluss in den Niederlanden
Written with Prof.Dr. Jürgen G. Backhaus, Maastricht, Netherlands.
First printed as:
Working paper. WP/96/012. (1996)
University of Limburg, Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Maastricht, Netherlands. (25 p.)
Later printed in:
Eugen Wendler (ed.) (1996). "Die Vereinigung des Kontinentes" – Friedrich List- Die gesamt-europäische Wirkungsgeschichte seines ökonomischen Denkens, Scäffer-Poeschel Verlag, Stuttgart 1997.This is an anthology celebrating the 150 year commemoration of Germany’s foremost economist historically, Friedrich List, with a foreword by the prime-minister of Baden-Würtemberg, Germany. (25 p.). With highly elaborate index and bibliography of old Dutch literature posted on a University of Limburg Internet address - some110 p. of bibliography)
Research done by :
Arno Mong Daastøl (Daastoel) (Drs. Oecon at Universität Erfurt, Germany)
Utsiktsveien 34, NO-1410 Kolbotn, Norway
Email: arno@daastol.com Ph: (prefix 47) 6680 6373, Mobile: 9002 4956, Fax: 6699 5325
Web: daastol.com , Creditary-Economics.org ; InnoTrans.Net ; SporTaxi.com ; AfriTrans.net
Content
ENTRIES FOUND ON THE VARIOUS CONCEPTS
REFERENCES TO PERSONS (In books)
SEARCH PROCEDURE
The search for information regarding how the ideas of F.List were received in the Netherlands was done through the National Dutch library system which includes most of all literature stored from around 1550 until today. For budget reasons it had to somewhat restricted - for example to the Dutch economic magazines available in Maastricht.
A search for `List' gave 57 entries as compared with the entries of other German scholars of the same tradition: Sombart: 121, Roscher: 46, Schmoller: 50, Knies: 10, Hildebrand: 2, A.Wagner: 42, J.H.G.Justi: 20, Möser: 1, Wollf: 184, Leibniz: 410 and Cusa + Kues: 160 + 198. The entries however were practically all non-Dutch texts and therefore were of less interest. Consulting a modern standard textbook on the history of Dutch economic ideas by van Daal and Heertje, two entries were found regarding the non-reception by two liberalists: Pierson and his student Beaujon. Nevertheless, the main works of practically all economists mentioned by van Daal and Heertje up to 1885, the main economists up to 1935 and a few thereafter were searched through.
Other books by authors mentioned by these main stream liberalist authors in connection with the main themes of interests regarding List's ideas were also scrutinized. In particular authors were sought who might be opposed to the main liberalist stream. These were mainly dissertations and pamphlets where the latter were of a more practical nature which often did not mention any theoreticians at all. All books covering Dutch economic-, tariff-, and trade history were scrutinized. The leading economic magazines were scrutinized in the same manner: De Gids through the years 1855-1885 (founded 1837) and de economist through the years 1852-1885. The ending-year 1885 was a matter of cost-benefit choice concerning time spent and information received.
The books and articles had to be scrutinized page by page. This procedure had to be repeated for practically all book as only about 5 per cent of the books released before WW II seem to have been given a index.
The search included also other economists, as well as concepts like "vrijhandel" and "het vrije ruilverkeer" (free trade), "protectie" and "bescherming" (protection), "tarivenpolitiek" (tariff policy), "handelspolitiek" (trade policy), katheder-socialist, historische school, "Zollverein" (German customs union), "spoorweg" (railroads) and concepts related to non-material factors of production.
Practically no references were found in these books to railroads, extremely few to customs union and then regarding German history and not theory. Regarding education there was a Malthusian bent towards viewing the education of common people into limiting their procreation rather than promoting technical development.
The results for most of the books were listed in a separate document were entries easily can be found by making an entry for example Adam Smith or Frederic Bastiat or Gustav Schmoller on a computer-text-program like Word Perfect which was the working program. The document had reached 40 pages when we decided to stop the search. There still is an amazing amount of pamphlets to be searched through, more than 200 known at present. This could not be done due to lack of time, lack of funds since each order costs 10 gulders and since many pamphlets simply are not available through the library system due to old age or scarcity. To review them would have meant a considerable amount of time (and money) spent on travelling to local libraries in the Netherlands.
The entries found in the Dutch library system on the various concepts were:
vrijhandel: 61
vrije ruilverkeer: 7
protectie: 54
protectionisme: 34
bescherming: 7
handelspolitiek: 108
tarivenpolitiek: 3
katheder-socialist: 3
historische school: 1
REFERENCES IN DUTCH LITERATURE TO PERSONS
Books and articles from which I have not listed all the names mentioned are marked with a *
But they have been looked through.
R.Häpke: `Die Wirtschaftspolitik im Königreich der Niederlände, 1815-1830', in Vierteljahrschrift für Sozial- und Wirtschaftsgeschichte (1923)
Willem van Houten: De Koophandel, Gebroeders Diederichs, Amsterdam 1836 (384p,)
Most likely no reference to List: too old and hardly any names mentioned at all
No index, no table of contents
Chapter on railroads 115
vrije of beperkte handel 80
Mr.D...: Over de aloude vrijheid van handel en nijverheid en Nederland, M.Ballot, Denveter 1840 (319p.)
Quote from List ??? Pages 301-302 or Schön as is written?
History of Dutch economy and tariffs
NO REGISTER
I limit the registration to foreign economists and some Dutch
Lots of references to Karl V, Philip II, Maximillian I
Physiocratism 311,
mercantilism 311,
Willem I 21,
Cromwell 86,306,
Louis XIV 94,
Colbert 102, "vollste success", 306,
Grawinckel 145,
Boxhorn 145,
Gronovius 145,
Heinsius 145,
Luzac 201,
Arthur Young 180,
Smith 182,299,303,307,
Baldwin 308,
Canning 308,
Strijd over vrijheid van handel 275,
Luzac 276,289,
Charlemagne and the blooming of Frisian manufacture 278,
Charlemagne 291,
Karl V 279,290,
John Bowring 291,315,
McCulloch 292,
Johann Schön 301,302,312,
B.W.A.E.Sloet tot Oldhuis: Voorede te: Staatshuihoudkunde of beginselen des rijkdoms, (translation from French) by Joseph Droz, J.de Lange, Denventer 1849
No reference to List
No register
Droz mentions:
Ganilh 30n
Storch 3
Colbert 63,148
E.W.de Rooy: Geschidenis der Staatshushoudkunde in Europa, an de vroegste tijden tot heden, Met eene voerede van Mr. D.A. Walraven, L.F.J.Hassels, Amsterdam 1851
No register
Economic history from Athens to 1550
No reference to List
E.W.de Rooij: Geschidenis van den Nederlandschen Handel, L.F.J.Hassels, Amsterdam 1856 (1030p.)
WITH REGISTER!!!
LIST IS NOT MENTIONED
no references to protection or to spoorwegen
J.A.Molster: De Geschiedenis der Staatshuishoudkunde, van de Vroegste Tijden tot Heden, Gebroeders Kraay, Amsterdam 1851
List p. 235
Cameral 235
Zollverein 233, 234
same pages: Rau, Osiander, Lotz, Riedel, Smitthenner, Hufeland, Hoffman,Fulfa, Muchard, Jacob, von Veller, and the Dutch Bosscha
Hendrik Muller S.zoon: De Nederlandsche Katoen-nijverheid en het stelsel van bescherming in Nederlandsch Indië, H.A.Kramers, Rotterdam 1857 (233p.)
no index, no chapters
practically oriented book
No reference to List
Hogendorp 35
graaf Schimmelpenninck 36,39,69,
Willem I 38
Zie 96
Jordaan 117
Dumayr van Twist 123
Meijer Bing 149
S.J.Hingst: Proeve eener geschiedenis der Historische School op het gebied van het privaatregt in Duitsland, Johannes Müller, Amsterdam 1859 (179p.)
No references to economists
No reference to List
Otto Van Rees: Geschiedenis der staatshuishoudkunde in Nederland tot het achttiende eeuw, 2 Vol., Kemink en zoon, Utrecht 1865-1868
Part I: Oorsprong en karakter van de Nederlandsche nijverheidspolitiek, der zeventiende eeuw.
Part II: Geschiedenis der koloniale politiek van de republiek der vereenigde Nederlanden.
No reference to List
No register
Rees mentions:
PART I:
Bodinus
Child
Colbert
Cromwell
Court
Graswinkel
Kluit
Laspeyres
Luzac
Petty
Roscher
Steuart
Willem I...
PART II:
Child
Hogendorp....
Luzac....
Pestel...
Richelieu 173
Usselinx....
S.van Houten: De Staatsleer van Mr.J.R.Thorbecke, Te Groningen bij J.B.Wolters, 1872 MU PH hV 11
No reference to List
J.Bosscha: Pruisen en Nederland, Een word van J.Bosscha, oud-minister, aan zijne landgenooten, Te Amsterdam, bij C.M.van Gogh. 1866 (49p.)
No reference to List
An article on Dutch independence from the Habsburgers, the French and the Germans through history since Charlemagne and of course since 1573
No references to economists
N.G.Pierson: Het begrep van volksrijkdom, P.N.van Kampen, Amsterdam 1864
List 77, 81,
Knies 81
German economists: 36
Historical school 104
Ganilh 36
Roscher 20,22,23,85,107
N.G.Pierson: Friedrich List en Zijn Tijd (Friedrich List and his time), de Gids, 1866, see also Economic Papers, volume II, pp.257-88
Many references to List of course
German railroads 370
National system 372
Pressed by Roscher, Hildebrand, Stein 375
List no unconditional protectionist 376
List's inconsequenct protectionism 382
N.G.Pierson: 'Het katheder-socialisme' (Katheder socialism), de Gids, 1878 3, pp.250-280, see also Economic Papers, volume I, pp.211-47
Many references on German economists of course
LIST 252,
Nederlandsche katheder-socialisten 255,256
Goeman Borgesius 256,262,263,276
l'Ange Huet 278
N.G.Pierson: Het stelsel van Bescherming, De erven F.Bohn, Haarlem 1885
LIST 34
Seckendorff 1,4
North 1
Smith 2,34
Bastiat 3
Say 6,14,
Boisguillebert 32,44
Loius XIV 32
van Horn 32
P.Verri 37,38
Falke: Geschichte des deutschen Zollwesens, 1869
Weber: Geschichte des Zollvereins, 1869
N.G.Pierson: Economist Januari 1888
List 34, 35
Seckendorf 1,4
North 1
Boisguilebert and Louis XIV 32,44
N.G.Pierson: Leerboek der Staatshuishoundkunde, De erwen F.Bohn, Haarlem 1896 MU EAF 334-7
NO INDEX
No reference to List
Looked up part two: chapters on protection: pp.189-241
No references to List despite many references to "de protectionisten".
Mentioned are:
Quesnay 189
Smith 189
Cobden 190
Thomas More 201
A.Beaujon 209
Paul Leroy Beaulieu 241
N.G.Pierson: Het waardeproblem in een socialistische Matschappij, De Economist, vol.41, S'Gravenhage 1902, pp.423-56, reprinted in Verspreide Economische Geschriften edited by C.A.Verrijn Stuart, Haarlem 1910, vol.I, pp.333-77, tranlated by G.Gardiner and published as The Problem of Value in the Socialist Community in F.Hayek, Collectivist Economic Planning, Routledge and Sons, London 1935, pp. 41-85
No reference to List
Denies what German writers insist on: that there is any relationship between Ricardo and Marx78
N.G.Pierson: Grondbeginselen der Staatshuishoundkunde, new ed., fifth printing, De erwen F.Bohn, Haarlem 1905 (349p.)
No index,
Looked only on chapter on "uit en invoer" and belastingen
LIST 265
Duitsche tolverbond 265
Lotz 261
Clement 263
Hogendorp 265
Sickenga 265
Sillem 265
Smith 265
Huskinson 265
graaf Caprivi 276
A.Raffalovich 279
A.E.Sayous 279
G.L.Porter 283
H.Paasche 283
Sauerbeck 285
Boissavian 285
Lincoln 285
Verri 291
d'Aulnis de Bourouill 295
P.Bruckner 297
chapter on belastingen
Ricardo 321,323
A.Soetbeer 322
MacCulloch 322
Inama Sternegg 329
Neumann 336
Folkert Nicolaas Sickenga:
Bijdrage tot de geschiedenis der belastingen in Nederland, Proefschrift Leiden, Academische Boekhandel van P.Engels, Leiden 1864
No register
No reference to List
Mentions negotiations with England and transit trade with Germany p. 197
Alkemade 20,21
Aitzema 133,148,210,311,318, 319,346
Berg 60,61,65,71,83,86,96
Boissevain 500
Boxhorn 44,68,70,76
Burman 15,49,
Bynkershoek 432
Cibrario 22
Citters 477,
de Coeur 328,
de la Court 156,166
Mr. D... 227,244,256,259,374,375,440,
Dirks 42
Engels 83,100,116,158,300,314,334,356,367,368,393,400,414,417,421,436,441,442,443,445,
Gibbon 22
Graswinckel 10,204,208,209,294
de Groot 136,497
Halsema 4,14,27,31,38,39,41,42,43,46,47
Hamerster 429
Hasse 491
Heeneman 6,7,8,30,33,75,78,82,
Heel 55
Heeren 327
Hoeven 146,146,147
Hogendorp 440
Huber 429
Idsinga 17,26,27,30,62
Karl de Groote 6
Kluit 8,22,34,35,36,82,476,
Koenen 133,375,455,466,474,
Laspeyres 294,315 2
Libertas 329
Le Long 242,416,459,463,467,475,
Leeuwen 12,14,16,29,30,476,477,481
L'Espine 416,467,475,
Loon 34,5,6,7,9,13,17,18,19,22,28,29,33,34,35,54,70,83
Luzac 92,230,231,244,245,246,247,248,249,258,260,263,273,284,380,408,409,423,440,441,460
Mac Culloch 198
Metelerkamp 457
Paulus Scheltus
56,83,87,103,109,113,114,115,116,117,381,395,
Pestel 263,264
Pinto 498
Pot 64,74,82,83,87,334,335
Quack 3
Raleigh 139
Reyd 63,80,103,135,156,318
Robertson 5,13,55
de Rooy 122,329
Say 224
Scheltus 102
vin Scheurl 491
Schotanus 39,40,44,46,48,87
Schrassert 27,67,73,286,293,332,333,354,382,480,
Seneuil 496,497
Slingelandt 71,75,81,103,107,108,109,110,111,112,113,244,285,295,300
Sminia 37,46
Smith,A 458
Spence 22
Spiegel 102,446,
Sterk 150,151,
Swinderen 340,341,
Tacitus 36
Temple 123
den Tex 145
Tongerlo 244
Toullier 493,495,
Vissering 198,427
Valckenier 192,191,
Vynckt 96
Wagen 255,256,264
Wagenaar 9,19,31,40,45,61,64,65,70,71,73,75,76,78,79,80,82,83,84,85,86,88,90,92,93,95,96,103,133,156,227,244,246,249,250,251,254,257,258,262,263,273,294,295,312,315,331,356,445,455,458,461,462,463,465,467,469,471,475
Wall 16,19,70,82
Walter 493
Wertheim 181,199,294
Westendorp 12,27,39,42,43,45,46,47,59
Willem IV V 375
Winsemius 80,81,84,85,87,101
Wttewall 211
Zillesen 367
Zurck 30,54,206,302,469,477,
F.N. Sickenga: Geschiedenis der Nederlandsche belastingen, P.N. van Kampen, Amsterdam 1865
No reference to List
French influence 106
F.N. Sickenga: Geschiedenis der Nederlandsche belastingen sedert het jaar 1810, 1883
Not borrowed
W.C.Mees: Overzicht van Eenige Hoofddoornstukken der Staatshuishoudkunde, P.N.van Kampen, Amsterdam 1866 (226p.)
No reference to List
No index, table of contents in the front
It is strange that almost none has commented on the relatively very large chapter by Mees on international trade III p.144-226
Very unusual book: One name is mentioned:
Robinson Crusoe 15
H.J.M.van de Laar: Oppenbanker en Wetenschapsman, Willem Cornelis Mees, 1813-1884, Martinus Nijhoff, Den Haag 1978.
No reference to List
H.W.Tijdeman: De Nederlandsche Handelsmaatschappij, Hazenberg, Leiden 1867
no register and no reference to List
a few references to Vissering, Mees and Hogendorp but to no foreigners
except
Thomas Stamford Raffles 3,62,65,384: "The History of Java"
Pinchegru 51
Willem I 236
Simon Vissering: Handboek van praktische Statshuishoudkunde, 2 vols., P.N. Kamen, Amsterdam 1867
Register
PART I
PART II references to paragraphs
2 Hoofdstuuk De Werking van de staat tot de maatschappij
1 handeheving 10
2 bescherming 13
3 ondersteuning 16
Interesting references inluding all foreign economists:
List en zijn nationale system 84 (p.48)
Bastiat
Bescherming 672-680 zie: Nijverheid en Staat
Carey 639, (pp.429,434)
Colbert 1097
Fourier
Gogel en besherming 89,94,118
Jackson
Law
Malthus
Mill
Montesquieu
Ondersteunning
Pinto
R.Price
Ricardo
Say
Smith
spoorwegen
Staatshandheven
Staatsschuld
Tolheving
Willem I 179,965
Simon Vissering: Handboek van praktische staatshuishoudkunde, 2 vol., vierde, herziene druk, P.N.van Kamen, Amsterdam 1878
List en zijn nationale system 84 (p.48) (same as above)
Simon Vissering and D.A.Portielje: Tariefshervorming in Engeland,
Not available
Hendrik Jacob Hamaker: De Historiscche School in de Statshuishoudkunde, - Academisch Proefschrift over, Gebroeders van der Hoek, Leiden 1870
List 18,19
Hildebrand 1,4,7,11,29
Kautz 2,10,22.
Knies 2,3,7,8,11,26n,27n,28n,29
Roscher 1,11,12,13,26n,27n,29
Vissering 10,11,18
Pierson 10,13,17,18
Houten 14,15,16
Fruin 14
J.L.de Bruyn Kops: Beginselen van staatshuishoudkunde, 2 vol., vijfde, herziene en vermeerede druk, J.H.Gerhard & Co., Amsterdam 1873
No register
PART I
1 Hoofdstuuk Waarde p.9
no references to any authors
2 Voortbrenging 18
no references to any authors
14 Handel 165-186
no references to any authors
18 Bemoeingen der regeering met de nijverheid 228
no references to any authors except: Colbert p. 229
19 Bescherming 241-297
no references to any authors except:
Richard Cobden 269-287
PART II
22 Belastingen 333
D'Aulnis de Bourouill: Katheder-socialisme, Redevoering bij de aanvardering van het Hoogleeraarsambt aan de Rijksuniversiteit te Utrecht, op den 23sten Maart 1878, Uitgesproken door Mr Baron D'Aulnis de Bourouill, J.L.Beijers, Utrecht 1878 (40p.)
No register
No reference to List
Wilhelm Roscher 14,15,21,22,33,35,37
Adolf Held 12,18,22,23,31,32,34,
Schmoller 14,34,35,
Brentano 34,35,
Adolph Wagner 30,33,34,
Levasseur 24,
Marx 31,33,
Smith 5,7,12,15,24,
Leone Levi 24,
Ricardo 15,
Malthus 15,24,
Senior 15,
Stuart Mill 15,20,23,24
Cairnes 15,
Jevons 15,
Say 5,6,
Courcelle Seneuil 7,
Emile de Lavaleye 7,
Heinrich von Treitschke 7,32,
Verein für Socialpolitik 8,
C.W.Opzoomer 11,
van Houten 11,
Vissering 11,
van Rees 38,
Ackerdijk 38,
Hemskeerk 37,
J.Bn.D'Aulnis de Bourouill: Praeadvies van Mr. J.Bn.D'Aulnis de Bourouill: in:
Prae-adviezen over de vraag: Is wijziging van de handelspolitik hier te lande wenschelijk? Vereeniging voor de Staatshuishoudkunde en de Statistiek, Jo.Müller, Amsterdam 1904, pp.1-25 (178p.)No register, table of contents in the front
LIST 6
Beaujon 6,9
Harte 7,8,9,10,
Pierson 8
Smith 8
Dusseldorp 10,14,15,
Stryen 10,
Marx 11,
M.Mees 12,15,
Pijnappel 12,
Smissaert 13
Chamberlain 15,16,19 !!!,
C.A.Vince 19,
Balfour 19
Bahlmann 20
van Tienhoven 20
U.G.Schilthuis: Praeadviezen van den heer U.G.Schilthuis, in: Prae-adviezen over de vraag: Is wijziging van de handelspolitik hier te lande wenschelijk? Vereeniging voor de Staatshuishoudkunde en de Statistiek, Jo.Müller, Amsterdam 1904, pp.26-81
No reference to List
Note this person who puplished a lot on construction of railroads and canals
This article is full of references to transportation to and from Germany
Bos 26,74, : "Het protectionisme en zijne volgen"
Smissaert 26,77.
Engels 27 : "Schutzzoll und Freihandel in der Neuen Zeit"
E.van Gelder 29
minister Pierson 29
Dobbelman 32,37,
Malthus 42
Bruinsma 43
F.B.Löhnis 43
Czar Peter den Grote 55
W.Toose 56
Thorbecke 59,64,
Minster Kuyper 63
van Heek 77
A.H.Jannink: Praeadviezen van den heer A.H.Jannink, in: Prae-adviezen over de vraag: Is wijziging van de handelspolitik hier telande wenschelijk? Vereeniging voor de Staatshuishoudkunde en de Statistiek, Jo.Müller, Amsterdam 1904, pp.82-114
No reference to List
A.Ledeboer 85
Chamberlain 85
Pierson 98,109,
J.van Dusseldorp: Praeadviezen van den heer J.van Dusseldorp A.Mzn., in: Prae-adviezen over de vraag: Is wijziging van de handelspolitik hier te lande wenschelijk? Vereeniging voor de Staatshuishoudkunde en de Statistiek, Jo.Müller, Amsterdam 1904, pp.115-178
LIST 129
Carey 160,161,
Treub 129
D.Bos 117
Beaujon 120,
Roscher 122,153,
Karl Marlo 153,154,178,
K.G.Winkelblech 154
Smith 126,129,160,
Say 126,130,131,134,135,154,
Pijnappel 132,
Bastiat 165,
Smissaert 172,173,174,175,177,178,
Pierson 134,135,136,1137,140,141,143,156,165,
Diepen 135,
Harte 135,
Schölvinck 135
Mill 135,
McCulloch 149,152,
J.A.Levy: Engelsch "Katheder-socialisme", Gebroeders Belinfante, 'S Gravenhage 1879 (443p.)
No reference to List
NO REGISTER
An attack on the essay by Pierson
Many refernces to Pierson, Cairnes, Spencer,Mill,
I only mention German authors
G.Rümelin 17,25,27,29,32,41,47,310,439
M.Müller 17,20
Kant 71,260,262,263,310
A.Wagner 82
Roscher 87, 318
Brentano 105,111,114,
Helferich 105,112,
Bluntschli 155
de Savorin Lohman 161,162,163
W.v.Humboldt 164
Ihering 165 ff 175,4423
Histoircal school same
Stahl 171
F.A.Lange 210,259,260,274,318,343,
Ed.Hartenst 259,260
L.v.Ranke 220
R.Eucken 269
E.Pfleiderer 272,280
A.Horwicz 279,281,
Wundt 279
Mommsen 279
Helmholtz 299,307
D.F.Strauss 299
Hans Gross 304
A.Held 334,348,352,355
A.Oncken 364
K.D.A.Röder 429
Aristoteles 427
J.A.Levy: Het ideele in Recht en Staat Personijke dinstvervulling, den Haag 1876, p.14
duty 404
Hobbes on protection 399
David Syme: Outlines of an industrial science, London 1876
J.G.Hintzen: Kolonialprotectionisme, geschreven naar aanleiding van brochure van den Heer Joseph Jacobson, Te Rotterdam bij M.Wyt & Zonen, 1880 (11p.)
No reference to List
Jos.Jacobson 3,5,6,7,10,
Hendrik Muller S.zoon 3,
Smith 9,
M.Mees: Een en ander over het stelsel van bescherming, M.Wyt & Zonen, Rotterdam 1882 (55p.)
No reference to List
overview in the back:
Erzieungszölle 8-10
Why has protection so many adherents? 51
Schützzoll 11
Gründungsmanie 18
Bismarck 53
Mongredien 56
No other names
M.Mees: Nadeelen van het protectionisme voor de werkende klassen, M.Wyt & Zonen, Rotterdam 1891
No reference to List
Hardly any mentioning of authors or references at all
except:
President Cleveland 67
Sir John B.Phear 62
Erziehungszölle 73,74
J.Spée: Vrijhandel of Bescherming? Een en ander over den invloed, dien het stelsel van het laissez-faire, laissez psser, op het ttoestand van handle, landbouw, scheepvaart en nijverheid in het akgemeen heeft uitgeoefend, Gebroders Binger, Amsterdam 1883 (70p.)
No reference to List
Attack on free traders: see foreword, in particular on Mees
Willem I 27,
Erzieungszzölle 26,27
Gründer-zwendel 26
Preussia 28
German expansionism 54
P.N.Muller 54,55,56,
Colbert 5,6
Hndrik Muller (Szoon?) 66,
Louis XIV 6,
Smith 5,7,8
Say 5,7,8,61
cobden 7,65,
Mees 9,10,11,12,16,18,24,25,28,29,33, etc. etc.
(refered to on practically on every page)
van Bosse 13,14,15,
Kamerdebatten 1850 14
Rossi 17,
Gössingen 46,
Everhardus Cornelis Godée: Het oude stelsel van den Vrijen Handel en het
NB !! moderne Protectionisme, Academisch proefschrift aan de Rijksuniversiteit van Utrecht 1883, J.P.Diehl 1883 (122p.)
No register but appendixes on: free trade vs protection taken from Augustus Mongredien, Bismarck's 1878 writing.
Chapter two (of four) is on List!!! p.38-58
Chapter three on change in German trade policy p.58-83
Chapter four on results of the above in Germany p.84 ff
????? Nationale en Cosmopolitische Huishoudkunde, Een vluugschrift naar de aanledning van het proefschrift
NB !!! van Mr.E.C.Godée: "Het oude stelsel van den Vrijen Handel en het moderne Protectionisme, Minkman & Co, Arnheim 1883 (167p.)
This is a detailed and sharp critisism of Godée's thesis by an anonymous writer (!!)
No Index, table of contents in the front
same chapters as with Godée, see in particular page V
see also description of List's "system" chapter two, p.76 ff
Anonymously: Curiositeiten van het Protectionisme, Nijgh & Van Ditmar, Rotterdam 1884 (72p.)
No register
B.M.Bahlmann 14,
Tilburgse industri 14ff
Ueberwälzung der steuer 35
Freetrader fanatisme 56,
vom Stein 57,
Galilei 57,
Cobden 57,
William III 57,
Stulta en Puera 57,
F.Bastiat 57,
Armand Diepen: Het verslag der Tilburgsche wol-industrie en Hendrik Muller Szoon, of, Bescherming contra vrijhandel, Snelpersdruk van N. Luijten, Tilburg 1887 (120p.)
Includes the original proposal from the Tilburg industry as an apendix
No reference to List
No register
Clearly a protectionist see p.40 on Colbert and p. 105
Discusses particularly criticism of the anti-protectionist
Hendrik Muller Szoon against the Tilburg wol-industrie,
his proposal, book and some articles of his in the NRC
21 sept 1886 or 7, 29 aug.,
Handelsblad
Frankfurter Zeitung
The Ministries Peel, Russell Gladstone, 39
Pierson 39,68,
Vissering 39,
Bryun Kops 40,
Say 40,
Colbert 40,
J.Spée 52,
Suyver 57,
Landbauw-comitée rapport 82ff
Cromwell's Act of navigation 99
Smith 100,
Armand Diepen: De jongste uitingen van het anti-protectionisme in Nederland, J.Noorduyn & Zoon, Gorinchem 1889
No reference to List
No register
A lot of space devoted to protection of grainproduction as with Bruyn Kops, discusses also Beaujon, partly Mees and particularly Pierson closely
but is a protectionist, see page 392 for example
Against the role of Holland as a trade country see page 209
References to many newspaper-articles and a few Dutch books:
Pierson: Leerboek, Grondbeginselen, Vissering: Handboek, Beaujon: Handelspolitiek, Stork: Twentsche katoennijverheid, Mees: Overzicht,
and one foreign book: Say: Traite d'economie politique
2 Afdeeling landbouw en landbouwbescherming 55
Hoofdstuuk VI de Nederlandsche economen en de theorie van Ricardo100
Een merkwerdig antwoord 119
3 Afdeeling Nijverheid en nijverheidbescherming 139
4 Afdeeling Handel en handelbescherming 191
Hoe de ahndel beschermd kan worden
5 Afdeeling Een wenig historie 253
De theorie
references to Beaujon, Pierson, Greven, Deking Dura, Patijn, Rozenraad, Say, Schölwinck, Van Houten: Bijdragen,
Hoofdstuuk 17 Hoe het effecten-argument bestreden werd 332
Hoofdstuuk 18 de Bevoordering van het binnenlandsche ruilverkehr 344
Hoofdstuuk 19 Dure landen zijn welvaarende landen 365
Mentions
de nederlandse protectionisten 30
Patijn 3,4,5,6,7,8,9,14,15,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,28,29,30,33,35
G,Pollet 5,36,37,
George Medley 33,34,35
Hendrik Muller 36,37,
Beaujon, 181,222,223,226,228,231,
Greven
Veegens
Schölvinck
Dekin